Abstract
In recent times, the debate as to whether the use of force or torture by the Nigerian military forces may be permitted in certain circumstances in Local and International law as a means of extracting and securing life-saving information from terrorist or other criminal elements. This is with a view to preventing unprecedented destructive terrorist threat not only in Nigeria but in sub-Sahara Africa and beyond is gaining momentum. In several occasions, the Nigerian security forces are confronted with the issue of justifying the use of physical persuasive tactics in order to obtain vital information from terrorist such as Boko Haran, ISWAP, bandits and others. This sometimes contravenes the basic principles of human right in the criminal justice system, wherein an accused is deemed innocent until proven guilty by a competent court of jurisdiction as well as other constitutionally guaranteed rights. On 23rd day of March 2022, the Abuja-Kaduna train was bombed by bandit-terrorist, killing eight persons while many were injured and over 60 persons kidnapped in Nigeria. The correctional facility for inmates at Kuje was attacked by ISWAP on 5th July 2022 and over 600 prison inmates escaped, including about 60 Boko haram fighters still at large till date. No doubt the primary responsibility of the State is to ensure the safety and security of lives and property, while the use of torture is absolutely prohibited under Local and International Law. Supposing the Nigerian military forces are aware of the Abuja-Kaduna terrorist bomb would go off in an undisclosed public place, and it may be impossible to get people out in time, to what extent can security personnel be permitted to resort to the use of physical force as a means of obtaining necessary important information as to the location of the bomb from the terrorist suspects before it goes off?. Again, what is the legal justification of temporarily legalizing a crime in order to prevent another likely bigger crime under International Law? Should the law be used to sacrifice a few in hopes that it would prevent harm to the majority? One way of tackling this dilemma may be to distinguish between the justification of the use of torture and culpability of the torturer. Therefore, the fact that torture was used as means of preventing a threat may not necessarily excuse the crime of the torture even though in matters of National security, there is always a waiver of the rule of law.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2023 Scholarly Journal of Advanced Legal Research