Abstract
This paper presented a comprehensive critique analysis of three journal publications in mathematics education: Abbas (2000), Olanrewaju (2023), and George and Kakraba (2023). The concept of critique, derived from the Greek word kritike meaning “faculty of judgement,” was explored as a systematic and evidence-based evaluation of scholarly work. The purpose of critique was to assess the credibility, validity, and contribution of research, thereby strengthening academic quality and promoting knowledge advancement. A good critique was characterized by objectivity, analytical reasoning, balance, constructiveness, and logical organization. The elements of an effective critique included an introduction, summary, analysis, interpretation, and conclusion, each designed to facilitate a holistic understanding of a study’s strength and weaknesses. The types of critique are theoretical, methodological, empirical, and practical-offered multiple lenses through which to examine educational research. Applying these frameworks, the study evaluated the methodological rigor, theoretical depth, and pedagogical contributions of the selected journals. Abbas (2000) emphasized cultural pedagogy through ethnomathematics; Olanrewaju (2023) highlighted the role of direct instruction in improving numeracy; and George and Kraraba (2023) examined the impacts video-aided instruction on students’ geometry achievement. Collectively, the analyses revealed that while each study contributed uniquely to mathematics education, they shared limitations in sample size, theoretical grounding, and generalizability. The importance of critique in mathematics education research was underscored by its role as a reflective and developmental tool that enhances methodological soundness, pedagogical innovation, and scholarly discourse. Through constructive critique, educators and researchers could refine teaching practices, strengthen curriculum design, and promote evidence-based decision-making. Ultimately, this paper underscored critique as an indispensable mechanism for improving the quality and impact of mathematics education research in Africa and beyond.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2026 International Journal of Research in Education and Sustainable Development