Abstract
Despite the growing recognition of human capital as a critical driver of competitiveness in service-oriented industries, evidence from developing economies suggests that investments in employees do not always translate into improved shareholder value. This study examines this paradox within the Nigerian insurance sector by analysing whether employee productivity and human capital expenditures generate measurable returns for shareholders. Using panel data from 21 insurance companies listed on the Nigerian Exchange Group over the period 2012–2023 (252 firm-year observations), the study applies Panel EGLS random-effects estimation to assess the influence of employee productivity and training and development costs on return on equity and return on investment. The findings reveal a persistent disconnect between human capital inputs and financial outcomes. Employee productivity shows no statistically significant relationship with either return on equity or return on investment, while training and development costs similarly fail to exert significant effects. The models exhibit very low explanatory power, indicating that gains in workforce capability are not effectively transmitted to shareholder returns. The study contributes evidence from a developing insurance market, challenging the assumed linear relationship between human capital investment and financial performance. It concludes that Nigerian insurers face structural and strategic constraints that prevent human capital investments from being efficiently converted into shareholder value, underscoring the need for improved alignment between human resource strategies, operational efficiency, and financial performance objectives.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2025 Research Journal of Management Practice